diff --git a/src/data/move.ts b/src/data/move.ts
index 717a9094c08..57b01e64c0e 100644
--- a/src/data/move.ts
+++ b/src/data/move.ts
@@ -19,6 +19,7 @@ import { Stat } from "./pokemon-stat";
 import { TerrainType } from "./terrain";
 import { SpeciesFormChangeActiveTrigger } from "./pokemon-forms";
 import { Species } from "./enums/species";
+import { ModifierPoolType } from "#app/modifier/modifier-type";
 
 export enum MoveCategory {
   PHYSICAL,
@@ -934,8 +935,9 @@ export class StealHeldItemChanceAttr extends MoveEffectAttr {
         return resolve(false);
       const heldItems = this.getTargetHeldItems(target).filter(i => i.getTransferrable(false));
       if (heldItems.length) {
-        const highestItemTier = heldItems.map(m => m.type.getOrInferTier()).reduce((highestTier, tier) => Math.max(tier, highestTier), 0);
-        const tierHeldItems = heldItems.filter(m => m.type.getOrInferTier() === highestItemTier);
+        const poolType = target.isPlayer() ? ModifierPoolType.PLAYER : target.hasTrainer() ? ModifierPoolType.TRAINER : ModifierPoolType.WILD;
+        const highestItemTier = heldItems.map(m => m.type.getOrInferTier(poolType)).reduce((highestTier, tier) => Math.max(tier, highestTier), 0);
+        const tierHeldItems = heldItems.filter(m => m.type.getOrInferTier(poolType) === highestItemTier);
         const stolenItem = tierHeldItems[user.randSeedInt(tierHeldItems.length)];
         user.scene.tryTransferHeldItemModifier(stolenItem, user, false, false).then(success => {
           if (success)
@@ -980,8 +982,9 @@ export class RemoveHeldItemAttr extends MoveEffectAttr {
         return resolve(false);
       const heldItems = this.getTargetHeldItems(target).filter(i => i.getTransferrable(false));
       if (heldItems.length) {
-        const highestItemTier = heldItems.map(m => m.type.getOrInferTier()).reduce((highestTier, tier) => Math.max(tier, highestTier), 0);
-        const tierHeldItems = heldItems.filter(m => m.type.getOrInferTier() === highestItemTier);
+        const poolType = target.isPlayer() ? ModifierPoolType.PLAYER : target.hasTrainer() ? ModifierPoolType.TRAINER : ModifierPoolType.WILD;
+        const highestItemTier = heldItems.map(m => m.type.getOrInferTier(poolType)).reduce((highestTier, tier) => Math.max(tier, highestTier), 0);
+        const tierHeldItems = heldItems.filter(m => m.type.getOrInferTier(poolType) === highestItemTier);
         const stolenItem = tierHeldItems[user.randSeedInt(tierHeldItems.length)];
         user.scene.tryTransferHeldItemModifier(stolenItem, user, false, false).then(success => {
           if (success)
diff --git a/src/modifier/modifier-type.ts b/src/modifier/modifier-type.ts
index 83b722ddf7c..258e79e3651 100644
--- a/src/modifier/modifier-type.ts
+++ b/src/modifier/modifier-type.ts
@@ -63,16 +63,35 @@ export class ModifierType {
     this.tier = tier;
   }
 
-  getOrInferTier(): ModifierTier {
+  getOrInferTier(poolType: ModifierPoolType = ModifierPoolType.PLAYER): ModifierTier {
     if (this.tier)
       return this.tier;
     if (!this.id)
       return null;
-    for (let tier of Utils.getEnumValues(ModifierTier)) {
-      if (!modifierPool.hasOwnProperty(tier))
-        continue;
-      if (modifierPool[tier].find(m => (m as WeightedModifierType).modifierType.id === (this.generatorId || this.id)))
-        return (this.tier = tier);
+    let poolTypes: ModifierPoolType[];
+    switch (poolType) {
+      case ModifierPoolType.PLAYER:
+        poolTypes = [ poolType, ModifierPoolType.TRAINER, ModifierPoolType.WILD ];
+        break;
+      case ModifierPoolType.WILD:
+        poolTypes = [ poolType, ModifierPoolType.PLAYER, ModifierPoolType.TRAINER ];
+        break;
+      case ModifierPoolType.TRAINER:
+        poolTypes = [ poolType, ModifierPoolType.PLAYER, ModifierPoolType.WILD ];
+        break;
+      default:
+        poolTypes = [ poolType ];
+        break;
+    }
+    // Try multiple pool types in case of stolen items
+    for (let type of poolTypes) {
+      const pool = getModifierPoolForType(type);
+      for (let tier of Utils.getEnumValues(ModifierTier)) {
+        if (!pool.hasOwnProperty(tier))
+          continue;
+        if (pool[tier].find(m => (m as WeightedModifierType).modifierType.id === (this.generatorId || this.id)))
+          return (this.tier = tier);
+      }
     }
     return null;
   }
@@ -1179,9 +1198,7 @@ let enemyIgnoredPoolIndexes = {};
 let enemyBuffModifierPoolThresholds = {};
 let enemyBuffIgnoredPoolIndexes = {};
 
-const tierWeights = [ 769 / 1024, 192 / 1024, 48 / 1024, 12 / 1024, 1 / 1024 ];
-
-export function regenerateModifierPoolThresholds(party: Pokemon[], poolType: ModifierPoolType, rerollCount: integer = 0) {
+export function getModifierPoolForType(poolType: ModifierPoolType): ModifierPool {
   let pool: ModifierPool;
   switch (poolType) {
     case ModifierPoolType.PLAYER:
@@ -1200,6 +1217,14 @@ export function regenerateModifierPoolThresholds(party: Pokemon[], poolType: Mod
       pool = dailyStarterModifierPool;
       break;
   }
+  return pool;
+}
+
+const tierWeights = [ 769 / 1024, 192 / 1024, 48 / 1024, 12 / 1024, 1 / 1024 ];
+
+export function regenerateModifierPoolThresholds(party: Pokemon[], poolType: ModifierPoolType, rerollCount: integer = 0) {
+  const pool = getModifierPoolForType(poolType);
+ 
   const ignoredIndexes = {};
   const modifierTableData = {};
   const thresholds = Object.fromEntries(new Map(Object.keys(pool).map(t => {
@@ -1360,27 +1385,22 @@ export function getDailyRunStarterModifiers(party: PlayerPokemon[]): Modifiers.P
 
 function getNewModifierTypeOption(party: Pokemon[], poolType: ModifierPoolType, tier?: ModifierTier, upgradeCount?: integer, retryCount: integer = 0): ModifierTypeOption {
   const player = !poolType;
-  let pool: ModifierPool;
+  const pool = getModifierPoolForType(poolType);
   let thresholds: object;
   switch (poolType) {
     case ModifierPoolType.PLAYER:
-      pool = modifierPool;
       thresholds = modifierPoolThresholds;
       break;
     case ModifierPoolType.WILD:
-      pool = wildModifierPool;
       thresholds = enemyModifierPoolThresholds;
       break;
     case ModifierPoolType.TRAINER:
-      pool = trainerModifierPool;
       thresholds = enemyModifierPoolThresholds;
       break;
     case ModifierPoolType.ENEMY_BUFF:
-      pool = enemyBuffModifierPool;
       thresholds = enemyBuffModifierPoolThresholds;
       break;
     case ModifierPoolType.DAILY_STARTER:
-      pool = dailyStarterModifierPool;
       thresholds = dailyStarterModifierPoolThresholds;
       break;
   }
diff --git a/src/modifier/modifier.ts b/src/modifier/modifier.ts
index 10a88d9506e..115273db744 100644
--- a/src/modifier/modifier.ts
+++ b/src/modifier/modifier.ts
@@ -1738,12 +1738,13 @@ export abstract class HeldItemTransferModifier extends PokemonHeldItemModifier {
       return false;
 
     const withinParty = pokemon.isPlayer() === targetPokemon.isPlayer();
+    const poolType = pokemon.isPlayer() ? ModifierTypes.ModifierPoolType.PLAYER : pokemon.hasTrainer() ? ModifierTypes.ModifierPoolType.TRAINER : ModifierTypes.ModifierPoolType.WILD;
 
     const transferredModifierTypes: ModifierTypes.ModifierType[] = [];
     const itemModifiers = pokemon.scene.findModifiers(m => m instanceof PokemonHeldItemModifier
         && (m as PokemonHeldItemModifier).pokemonId === targetPokemon.id && m.getTransferrable(withinParty), targetPokemon.isPlayer()) as PokemonHeldItemModifier[];
-    let highestItemTier = itemModifiers.map(m => m.type.getOrInferTier()).reduce((highestTier, tier) => Math.max(tier, highestTier), 0);
-    let tierItemModifiers = itemModifiers.filter(m => m.type.getOrInferTier() === highestItemTier);
+    let highestItemTier = itemModifiers.map(m => m.type.getOrInferTier(poolType)).reduce((highestTier, tier) => Math.max(tier, highestTier), 0);
+    let tierItemModifiers = itemModifiers.filter(m => m.type.getOrInferTier(poolType) === highestItemTier);
 
     let heldItemTransferPromises: Promise<void>[] = [];